Skip to content

Human Factors in Aviation: The Dirty Dozen and the SHELL Model

By admin /

Aircraft and systems have become extremely reliable, so most accidents today involve human performance somewhere in the chain: a missed check, a misunderstanding on the radio, a tired engineer. Human factors is the study of how people interact with machines, procedures, the environment and each other – and how to design work so that the inevitable errors are caught before they cause harm. It is required training for pilots, cabin crew, engineers and air traffic controllers.

The Dirty Dozen

The "Dirty Dozen" is a list of twelve common preconditions for human error, first developed for aircraft maintenance by Transport Canada in the early 1990s. Each one comes with a typical safety net:

  1. Lack of communication – use clear handovers, written logs and read-backs.
  2. Complacency – train yourself to expect to find a fault; never sign for what you did not check.
  3. Lack of knowledge – get training on the task and use current manuals.
  4. Distraction – after an interruption, go back three steps in the task.
  5. Lack of teamwork – discuss how the job will be done and who does what.
  6. Fatigue – recognise the signs, plan rest and ask others to check critical tasks.
  7. Lack of resources – order parts and tools early; do not improvise.
  8. Pressure – communicate concerns; ask for extra time or help rather than cutting corners.
  9. Lack of assertiveness – speak up when something is not right, even to seniors.
  10. Stress – be aware of it, take a short break and talk to colleagues.
  11. Lack of awareness – think about what could go wrong and how your task affects others.
  12. Norms – the "we always do it this way" shortcuts; follow the procedure, and challenge unsafe norms.

The SHELL model

The SHELL model (developed by Edwards and later Hawkins) puts the human – Liveware – in the centre and looks at its interfaces with four elements:

  • Software – procedures, checklists, manuals, symbols and computer programs.
  • Hardware – the aircraft, controls, displays and tools.
  • Environment – heat, noise, lighting, weather, time of day and the organisation's climate.
  • Liveware – other people: crew members, controllers, engineers and managers.

Problems arise where the interfaces do not match – for example, a confusing checklist (L–S), a poorly placed switch (L–H), working in a hot ramp at 3 a.m. (L–E), or a cockpit where the first officer will not challenge the captain (L–L).

The Swiss cheese model

Professor James Reason described an organisation's defences as slices of Swiss cheese: training, procedures, supervision, equipment and checks. Each slice has holes – latent conditions and active failures. An accident happens only when the holes in several slices line up. Human factors work tries to add slices and shrink the holes, rather than simply blaming the last person in the chain.

Crew Resource Management (CRM)

CRM training grew out of accidents where a technically sound crew failed to work as a team. It teaches communication, leadership, assertiveness, decision-making, workload management and situational awareness. Similar programmes exist for engineers (maintenance resource management) and controllers (team resource management).

Applying human factors at work

  • Use checklists and standard phraseology – they protect against memory lapses and misunderstanding.
  • Read back critical information such as clearances, frequencies and fuel figures.
  • Manage fatigue through rostering rules and honest self-assessment.
  • Report errors and near misses, so the organisation can fix the conditions behind them.

Test yourself: the free aviation skill test has unit-wise questions for every BBA, BSc and MBA aviation subject, and you can try flying in your browser with the free Dr. M.G.R. Flight Simulator.

Frequently asked questions

What are the Dirty Dozen in aviation?

Twelve common causes of human error: lack of communication, complacency, lack of knowledge, distraction, lack of teamwork, fatigue, lack of resources, pressure, lack of assertiveness, stress, lack of awareness and norms.

What does SHELL stand for?

Software, Hardware, Environment and Liveware, with the human (Liveware) at the centre interacting with each of the others.

What is the Swiss cheese model?

James Reason’s model in which an organisation’s defences are slices with holes; an accident happens when the holes in several defences line up.

Is human factors training compulsory?

Yes. Human factors and crew resource management training are required for pilots, cabin crew, engineers and controllers under ICAO standards and DGCA regulations.